At first glance, Paul’s command that women “keep silent in the churches” can sound like an all-inclusive prohibition against speaking. But is that what silent means in the immediate context?
Paul uses the same Greek verb three times in 1 Corinthians 14.
A person speaking in tongues must be silent when there is no interpreter:
But if there is no one to interpret, let each of them keep silent in church.
—1 Corinthians 14:28
A prophet must become silent when another receives a revelation:
If a revelation is made to another sitting there, let the first be silent.
—1 Corinthians 14:30
Then women are told to be silent:
The women should keep silent in the churches.
—1 Corinthians 14:34
The Greek verb in all three places is σιγάω (sigaō): to be silent, stop speaking, or refrain from speaking. In verses 28 and 30, Paul uses σιγάτω—“let him be silent.” In verse 34, he uses the plural form, σιγάτωσαν—“let them be silent.”
That is the only difference. Paul changes the number because he moves from one person to multiple women. He does not change the meaning of the verb.
“Be silent,” “keep silent,” and “remain silent” are English translation choices. There is no separate Greek word for keep or remain in verse 34.
This matters.
We know that sigaō cannot mean “never speak in church” because the tongue-speaker and the prophet are not permanently prohibited from speaking. They must be silent under particular circumstances so that the gathering remains orderly.
The immediate context helps us understand the restriction placed on women. Prophets speak while others weigh—or judge—what has been said (verse 29). Women must not assume authority over men by publicly judging the prophecies of male speakers.
They must also remain silent while someone else is speaking rather than interrupting with questions directed to their husbands. If they desire to learn something, Paul tells them to “ask their husbands at home” (verse 35).
The foundation is creation order and headship. What does that foundation look like when it is applied? Women must not teach or exercise authority over men.
Yet Paul also gives instructions for women who pray or prophesy:
Every wife who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonors her head.
—1 Corinthians 11:5
How can women be told to pray or prophesy with covered heads in chapter 11 and then be told to remain silent in chapter 14?
The two chapters do not contradict each other; they explain each other.
Chapter 11 tells us how women may pray and prophesy while visibly honoring headship: they must do so with covered heads. Chapter 14 tells us when they must remain silent: when speaking would interrupt worship or exercise authority over men.
The tongue-speaker, the prophet, and the women are all told to sigaō—to refrain from speaking under the circumstances Paul describes. The difference is not in the meaning of silent, but in who must be silent and when.
To be clear, in the church where we are members, women do not lead prayer or proclaim the Word during Lord’s Day services. Women do pray aloud during our Wednesday evening prayer gathering, and I am happy with the way our church orders these gatherings.
Recognizing that Paul’s command is not an absolute ban on every word spoken by a woman does not mean that every church must include every biblically permissible form of participation in its Lord’s Day worship. It means that we should allow chapters 11 and 14 to stand together—each helping us understand the other.
No comments:
Post a Comment